SPY covered calls were nearly a wash
I ran the standard setup on SPY: a 0.30-delta call, 30 days out, rolled every month. The calls collected 8.6% a year in premium. Buying back the ones that finished above the strike cost 9.4% a year. Net from the calls: -0.8% a year.
Total return points the same way. The covered-call version made +14.9% a year and plain holding made +15.4%, a gap of -0.5% a year, small enough that I read it as a tie. If you want the longer argument for why a broad index behaves this way, the covered call guide covers the mechanics.
Part of the reason is volatility. SPY's typical volatility in this backtest was 12%, against a median of 30% across the 104 tickers I tested, so the premium is small and the 0.30-delta strike sat only 2.9% above the price on average. The bigger part is drift. A 0.30-delta call is priced to finish in the money roughly 30% of the time, yet these finished there 41% of the time, because SPY kept climbing through most of the years in the table. Each of those months turned into a buyback.
Which years the calls helped and which they hurt
The year-by-year results show the pattern. The two worst years for the calls were both strong rallies: 2024, when the stock rose +24.9% and the covered-call version +20.2% (-4.7 pts), and 2017 (-6.8 pts). A rally alone does not explain it, though. In 2021 SPY rose +28.7% and the calls still came out ahead by +1.9 pts, and in 2025 by +3.9 pts.
The down years were mixed. In 2022, the bear year, holding returned -18.2% and the covered-call version -16.0%, a cushion of +2.2 pts, smaller than the edge the calls had in 2025. In 2018, the other losing year, the two were nearly level (+0.2 pts). The table also shows +5.0 pts for 2020, the largest gap in the calls' favour, but I would not trust it: the model prices 2020 premiums from past volatility, and real option prices after the March crash were well below that, so the calls' result is likely flattered.
| Year | Stock | Covered call | Difference (pts) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2016 partial | +4.7% | +2.5% | -2.2 pts |
| 2017 | +21.7% | +14.9% | -6.8 pts |
| 2018 | -4.6% | -4.4% | +0.2 pts |
| 2019 | +31.2% | +28.5% | -2.7 pts |
| 2020 | +18.4% | +23.4% | +5.0 pts |
| 2021 | +28.7% | +30.6% | +1.9 pts |
| 2022 | -18.2% | -16.0% | +2.2 pts |
| 2023 | +26.2% | +26.0% | -0.2 pts |
| 2024 | +24.9% | +20.2% | -4.7 pts |
| 2025 | +17.7% | +21.6% | +3.9 pts |
| 2026 partial | +13.7% | +11.0% | -2.6 pts |
Read 2020 with care: the model estimates option prices from recent price swings, which ran far above what options actually cost in the weeks after the March crash, so it overstates the premium collected then. Real buy-write funds trailed the S&P 500 in 2020.
Calendar-year total returns; the covered call is averaged over every start date, as in the chart above.
March 2020: the drawdown the calls did not fix
Selling calls is often described as downside protection. SPY's worst stretch is a fair test. From Feb 2020 to Mar 2020 the stock's drawdown was -34% peak to trough, and the covered-call version's was -33%. Almost no difference: a month's premium barely registers against a crash that size.
The more interesting month is the one right after. In the 30 days starting in Mar 2020, SPY bounced +25%, and closing the call sold at the start of that stretch cost 11.2% of the share price, the worst single month for the strategy. The calls did little for the crash and clipped the rebound. The year's +5.0 pts for the calls is probably a product of the model's overpriced premiums, so I would not set it against that one costly month.
What the other setups did
Out of the six presets I tested, moving the strike changed the answer more than moving the expiry. The aggressive 0.40-delta call netted -3.0% a year and finished in the money 56% of the time; the conservative 0.15-delta call netted +0.9%, in the money 12% of the time.
Only the three setups that left the most room above the price netted positive: the 0.15-delta call at +0.9%, the +10% strike at +0.7% and the +20% quarterly call at +0.4%. They finished in the money 12%, 2% and 1% of the time. On an index that rose more often than it fell, a strike nearer the price was overrun more often, and the buyback outweighed the premium.
Among the other index ETFs I tested, SPY ranked 3 of 5 on net from the calls over Oct 2021 – Oct 2026, the common window I use to compare tickers, with -0.5% a year. Over that window IWM came in at +0.3%, VTI at -0.2%, DIA at -1.0% and QQQ at -2.0%. For a broader look across all 104 tickers, see the rankings.
If you own 100 shares today
One contract covers 100 shares, and at $769 a share that is $76,909 of SPY. The modeled 30-day 0.30-delta call today has a strike of $786, which is +2.2% above the price, and a premium of $3.80 a share, or $380 a contract. That is 0.49% of the price. These premiums are modeled from historical volatility, not live quotes, so check a real option chain before comparing.
Many people looking at SPY covered calls also look at funds that sell the calls for them. I compared those in the covered-call ETF guide, and there is a direct XYLD vs SPY page. To test a strike and expiry of your own, use the calculator.
SPY wheel strategy backtest — cash-secured puts plus covered calls on the same stock.
Covered calls on similar tickers: