Tesla's 28.0% premium against a 58.3% buyback bill
Each month I wrote a 30-day 0.30-delta call on 100 TSLA shares, and the modeled premium came to 28.0% of the share price a year. Closing or settling those calls cost 58.3% a year, so the options netted -30.3% a year.
The covered-call version still made money, +17.2% a year, but holding returned +39.0%. That leaves the calls 21.8 pts a year behind.
Part of the reason the premium is large is that Tesla's typical volatility is 49%, where the median across the 104 tickers is 30%. My model priced that volatility into the premium, and the stock still moved more than the premium covered.
2020: +743.4% for holders, and a month that cost 90.7%
One year does most of the talking. In 2020 Tesla rose +743.4%. The covered-call version still gained +168.6%, which sounds like a triumph until you read the last column: a difference of -574.8 pts. Nothing else in the table comes close. The +168.6% is also likely flattered, because after the 2020 crash real option prices were well below what the model's volatility implies, so the premiums I credit for that year are probably too high.
The worst month sits inside that year. In the 30 days starting in Jan 2020 the stock rose +100%, and closing the call sold at the start of that stretch cost 90.7% of the share price at the time it was sold. The average 0.30-delta strike sat only 11.3% above the price, so the stock did not drift through it, it was gone past it.
2020 is not the only case. In each of the six years the stock gained +25.7% or more, the calls trailed. Besides 2020 that meant 2017 (-30.0 pts), 2019 (-5.7 pts), 2021 (-11.3 pts), 2023 (-56.1 pts) and 2024 (-40.2 pts).
| Year | Stock | Covered call | Difference (pts) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2016 partial | +6.5% | +6.4% | -0.1 pts |
| 2017 | +45.7% | +15.7% | -30.0 pts |
| 2018 | +6.9% | +9.1% | +2.2 pts |
| 2019 | +25.7% | +20.0% | -5.7 pts |
| 2020 | +743.4% | +168.6% | -574.8 pts |
| 2021 | +49.8% | +38.5% | -11.3 pts |
| 2022 | -65.0% | -60.1% | +4.9 pts |
| 2023 | +101.7% | +45.6% | -56.1 pts |
| 2024 | +62.5% | +22.3% | -40.2 pts |
| 2025 | +11.4% | +23.6% | +12.3 pts |
| 2026 partial | -19.4% | -7.1% | +12.3 pts |
Read 2020 with care: the model estimates option prices from recent price swings, which ran far above what options actually cost in the weeks after the March crash, so it overstates the premium collected then. Real buy-write funds trailed the S&P 500 in 2020.
Calendar-year total returns; the covered call is averaged over every start date, as in the chart above.
The years the calls came out ahead
The calls led in three full years and in the partial 2026. In 2018 the stock rose 6.9% and the covered-call version 9.1%, a difference of +2.2 pts. In 2022 it was -65.0% against -60.1%, or +4.9 pts, in the middle of a -74% fall from Nov 2021 to Jan 2023 (-73% with calls).
The two newer results are bigger. In 2025 the stock rose +11.4% and the covered-call version returned +23.6%, a difference of +12.3 pts, the best full year against holding. That is a year when the stock went up and the covered-call version still finished ahead. The partial 2026 row shows -19.4% for the stock and -7.1% with calls, a difference of +12.3 pts.
So the calls came out ahead in the quiet or falling years (2018, 2022 and so far 2026) and in 2025, and not by enough to offset the six big up years. Over the 10 years the calls finished in the money in 29% of months.
Last of six Autos & EV stocks, even on a shorter window
Rivian and Lucid listed too recently to have a full history, so the sector comparison runs over Oct 2021 – Oct 2026, the stretch all six share, rather than on Tesla's own ten years. Over it, Tesla's calls netted -16.1% a year, and it still ranks 6 of 6.
The calls added something for just one of the six, Lucid, at +5.8%. After it came NIO at -0.4%, Rivian at -2.9%, GM at -3.8% and Ford at -3.9%. Over that window, holding Tesla returned +4.6% a year and the covered-call version -4.2%.
If you own TSLA today
On 2026-10-15 TSLA closed at $362, with a modeled volatility of 40%. A 30-day, 0.30-delta call would sit at a $389 strike, +7.3% above the price, for a modeled premium of $5.90 a share, or $590 per contract (1.63% of the price). I built those figures from the model, so a live quote will differ. A round lot of 100 shares costs $36,244.
None of the six setups I tested made money from the calls. The conservative 0.15-delta call lost the least, -20.5% a year, and finished in the money only 17% of the time. The aggressive 0.40-delta setup lost the most, -32.9%, with 39% of calls ending in the money.
A strike +10% above the price lost slightly more than the standard setup, -31.5% against -30.3%, and finished in the money 30% of the time against 29%. Moving the strike or the expiry barely helped: even the quarterly +20% setup lost -27.9%, with 33% of its calls finishing in the money, because Tesla's upward drift kept carrying it past the strike. The calculator lets you try other strikes and expiries, and the full rankings place Tesla among all 104 stocks.
TSLA wheel strategy backtest — cash-secured puts plus covered calls on the same stock.
Covered calls on similar tickers: