Covered call ETFs

XYLD vs SPY

XYLD and SPY are exchange-traded funds. Both provide S&P 500 exposure, but XYLD sells monthly at-the-money index calls for income, while SPY retains the index's uncapped upside.

Compare total returns

Distributions reinvested · XYLD, SPY

XYLDSPY

October 18, 2021 – October 16, 2026

$8,000$10,000$12,000$14,000$16,000$18,00020222023202420252026
FundTotal returnAnnualized / yrEnding valueMax drawdown

Annualized return compounds over the selected period. Drawdown is the largest fall from a previous peak within that period.

XYLD vs SPY: which returned more?

From Oct 2021 to Oct 2026, SPY returned +13.0% a year against +7.5% for XYLD, with every distribution reinvested — $10,000 grew to $18,391 versus $14,321. SPY came out ahead in 3 of the 4 full calendar years.

XYLD was the smoother ride: its worst peak-to-trough fall was -19% against -24% for SPY, with day-to-day volatility of 11% vs 17%. The calmer fund also returned less over this window — a smoother ride usually costs some return.

Year by year

YearXYLDSPY

What each fund does

  • XYLD (Global X S&P 500 Covered Call ETF) holds the S&P 500 and sells at-the-money S&P 500 index calls on the whole portfolio every month — high income, almost no upside.
  • SPY (S&P 500 ETF) is a plain S&P 500 index fund — no options, all the upside and all the downside.

A high distribution yield is not the same as a high return. The figures above are total returns, so they already count every payout; a fund that pays out more but grows less can leave you with less. In a taxable account, distributions are also taxed as they arrive.

Or sell the calls yourself

With at least 100 shares of the underlying, you can run the same idea yourself and choose the strike: see the SPY covered call backtest, the full covered-call ETF comparison, or price a trade in the covered call calculator.

More head-to-head comparisons

Daily closing prices adjusted for distributions, from stockanalysis.com; returns are after each fund's fees. The window starts on the first day every fund shown traded, within our data (which begins in late 2021). Not investment advice.