Did the rich PLTR premium pay off?
No. Not over this period. Selling a 30-day 0.30-delta call on PLTR brought in a modeled 32.2% of the stock price per year. It comes from a stock whose typical volatility is 57% against a median of 30% across the 104 tickers I track.
Buying back or settling the calls that finished in the money cost 63.5% a year, so the calls netted -31.3% a year. The covered-call version of PLTR returned +44.0% a year while simply holding returned +65.4%, a gap of -21.4 pts a year.
Here is the odd part. Over Oct 2021 – Oct 2026, the window I use to compare all the tickers, PLTR ranks 2 of 104 stocks by covered-call return, so even the handicapped version beat nearly everything else. Among the 10 software stocks I track it ranks 10 of 10 on what the calls added over that window. A great stock can still be a poor fit for the strategy, because the calls tax exactly the days you most want to keep.
A spike, an 85% crash, then the 2024 rally
It opened with a spike. In the 30 days starting in Nov 2020, weeks after the listing, the stock rose +153%, and closing the call sold at the start of that stretch cost 137.9% of the share price at the time. That month is a large part of why the partial 2020 row trails holding by 57.3 pts.
PLTR's history then splits into two halves, and the calls behaved differently in each. From Jan 2021 to Dec 2022 the stock fell -85% from peak to trough. The covered-call version fell -79% over the same stretch.
In 2021 the stock lost -22.7% while the covered-call version lost -12.3%, a gain of +10.3 pts from the calls. In 2022 the stock lost -64.7% against -52.3% with calls, a gain of +12.5 pts. Those were the only two years the calls beat holding, and 2022 was the calls' best year against holding.
Then the stock turned. 2023 gave +167.4% for holders and +91.8% for call sellers, a difference of -75.6 pts. 2024 was the damage year: the stock rose +340.5% and the calls capped it at +159.1%, a difference of -181.4 pts. Even 2025, with the stock up +135.0%, left the call seller behind, a difference of -17.6 pts.
| Year | Stock | Covered call | Difference (pts) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 partial | +132.5% | +75.1% | -57.3 pts |
| 2021 | -22.7% | -12.3% | +10.3 pts |
| 2022 | -64.7% | -52.3% | +12.5 pts |
| 2023 | +167.4% | +91.8% | -75.6 pts |
| 2024 | +340.5% | +159.1% | -181.4 pts |
| 2025 | +135.0% | +117.4% | -17.6 pts |
| 2026 partial | +12.8% | +9.8% | -3.0 pts |
Read 2020 with care: the model estimates option prices from recent price swings, which ran far above what options actually cost in the weeks after the March crash, so it overstates the premium collected then. Real buy-write funds trailed the S&P 500 in 2020.
Calendar-year total returns; the covered call is averaged over every start date, as in the chart above.
Why a rally this big breaks the arithmetic
A 30-day call at 0.30 delta sat on average 13.6% above the share price, and the stock finished above that strike in 30% of the monthly cycles. That sounds like a comfortable cushion. For a stock that can move more than that in a single month (Nov 2020: +153%), it is not.
When a stock climbs through the strike, the seller keeps the premium but gives up everything above the strike. Repeat that through a trend as steep as 2023 and 2024 and the lost upside piles up faster than any premium can refill it. The rich premium was the market's price for that volatility, and the rally turned out to be worth far more than the premium.
I should be upfront about the sample. Palantir listed in 2020, so the price history here starts in October 2020 and runs about 6 years, while most other tickers in my set have up to 10. That window includes a crash and a historic recovery, so it is a strong test but a short one.
How software peers compare
PLTR is the outlier in its sector. Ranked by what the calls added per year over Oct 2021 – Oct 2026, ServiceNow came out at +1.5% and Adobe at +0.3%. Salesforce was at -2.2%, Shopify at -2.9%, Snowflake at -5.7% and Cloudflare at -8.9%.
Over that same window PLTR's figure was -27.0%, far below all of them. NOW and ADBE were the only software names where the calls added anything; PLTR ranks last of all 10.
If you own PLTR today
On the latest data in the backtest, with the stock at $201 and a modeled volatility of 48%, a 30-day 0.30-delta call would sit at a $218 strike, +9.0% above the price. The modeled premium is $3.88 a share, or $388 per contract, about 1.93% of the price. These are model outputs, not market quotes. Real bids will differ. A call 10% above the price would carry a 0.28 delta in the same model.
The other setups did not rescue the result, but some hurt less. The 45-day call at 0.30 delta lost the least, -20.4% a year, finishing in the money 27% of the time; the aggressive 0.40-delta call lost the most, -34.5%.
The fixed +10% strike finished in the money 36% of the time against 30% for the standard setup, and netted -31.6% against -31.3%. In a stock that kept climbing, a strike nearer the price simply gets overtaken more often.
Every one of them was negative. The ones that gave up the least were those that sold less often or farther from the price. The wheel strategy returned +31.0% a year here, 34.3 pts a year behind holding. To try your own strike and expiry, use the calculator, and see how PLTR stacks up in the full rankings.
PLTR wheel strategy backtest — cash-secured puts plus covered calls on the same stock.
Covered calls on similar tickers: